She currently lives in Germany, where she is the Director of the Einstein Forum in Potsdam. In 2013, she became Professor of Early Childhood and Literacy Education, and Chair of the Department of Teaching and Learning at NYU's Steinhardt School of … She currently lives in Germany, where she is the Director of the Einstein Forum in Potsdam. Pro-palästinensische BDS-Bewegung - Antisemitismus oder nur Kritik an Israels Regierung? Since the passing of the Bundestag resolution, numerous artists and intellectuals, including Jews, have been disinvited from scheduled events or boycotted because they criticise the policies of the Israeli government or defend the rights of Palestinians. • Learning from the Germans: Confronting Race and the Memory of Evil by Susan Neiman is published by Allen Lane (£20). The resolution accused the BDS of anti-Semitism. Jeder, der sagt: Ich bin für BDS, kann für BDS sprechen. Notprogramme der Politik sollen sie finanziell stützen. [...] a time when critical positions toward the Israeli government are equated with anti-Semitism, while nationalist and openly racist forces gain momentum.”, The American philosopher Susan Neiman, director of the Einstein Forum Potsdam for the past 20 years, told Deutschlandfunk radio that as a Jew she reacted angrily when no reference was made of the broad range of Jewish discussion worldwide, but instead only very conservative voices could be heard. Combine Editions. Die vom Bundestag erfolgte Distanzierung zur BDS-Bewegung und ihre Einstufung als antisemitisch ist laut dem Wissenschaftlichen Dienst des Bundestages eine "Meinungsäußerung ohne rechtliche Bindung". 0. She is the director of the Einstein Forum in Potsdam, Germany and a member of the Berlin-Brandenburg Academy of Sciences. Following an appeal, Germany’s Higher Administrative Court justified the plaintiff’s motion in November 2020. Susan Neiman is a moral philosopher and essayist. International Committee of the Fourth International, Israeli premier demands German government stop funding Jewish Museum Berlin, Berlin’s Jewish Museum director Peter Schäfer forced to resign, Dortmund, Germany withdraws prestigious award from the author Kamila Shamsie over support for BDS, US State Department moves to suppress criticism of Israel. Susan Neiman’s books. Susan Neiman im Gespräch mit Vladimir Balzer. In Germany, it assumed the most pernicious, murderous form with the Holocaust. Susan Neiman Average rating: 3.94 Darum heiße es, wachsam zu sein. The accusation of anti-Semitism against leftists and intellectuals plays into the hands of right-wing radicals and fascists—such as Donald Trump, Viktor Orbán, Matteo Salvini, Rodrigo Duterte and the AfD—who identify with the racist policies of the Israeli government and have been greeted jubilantly as state guests in Jerusalem. And stormy. An interview with Susan Neiman and Andreas Huyssen The conference “Ottoman Armenians during the decline of the empire: Issues of scientific responsibility and democracy”, held at Istanbul Bilgi University in 2005, marked the beginning of a fierce public debate on the “Armenian issue” in Turkey. The Left Party also introduced its own motion, which condemned BDS in the same manner as the government motion but included a few phrases about reconciliation between Jews and Palestinians. Aber die Hilfen haben Lücken, sagt Schauspielerin Julischka Eichel.Mehr, Bundestagsbeschluss zu BDS ohne rechtliche Wirkung, Debatte über BDS-Bewegung - "Antizionisten interessieren sich nicht für Palästinenser". The December statement by the cultural institutions now makes clear that the real aim of the all-party Bundestag resolution was not to combat anti-Semitism, but rather to suppress freedom of expression. In dieser Bewegung gibt es sicherlich Stimmen, die antisemitisch sind. Es geht nicht anders.". 2 the 20th century. Ein begrüßenswerter Vorstoß. More than 1,000 artists from Germany, Israel and around the world have lent their support to the statement. 6. (Deutschlandfunk Kultur, Fazit, 16.12.2020), BDS-Resolution des Bundestages - Zensur von Wissenschaft und Kultur? Eit gets loud. Die Tabuisierung der Debatte über Nahost und die Politik des Staates Israel gegenüber den Palästinensern sieht Neiman durch die "Heftigkeit der Reaktionen auf unsere Initiative" bestätigt. It includes a preamble, definition, and a set of 15 guidelines that provide detailed guidance for those seeking to recognize antisemitism in order to craft responses. But in other countries, it also serves the ruling class as a means of deflecting the anger of mostly petty-bourgeois layers of the population threatened with social decline by directing them against the Jewish part of the population. Her latest book is Moral Clarity: A Guide for Grown-Up Idealists (2008). The final chapter in his new book, “A Short History of Antisemitism” (in German), is devoted to BDS and the Bundestag resolution. Kulturschaffende wie Susan Neiman und Thomas Oberender wenden sich gegen den paternalistischen Tenor der BDS-Resolution. February 18, 2021. Reports of antisemitic incidents continue to rise in Germany. Susan Neiman, the director of the 'Einstein Forum' in Potsdam was introduced as a Jewish philosopher. The heart of the matter lies in a resolution passed in May 2019 by the Bundestag, the German parliament. “The whole debate over BDS was rife with the clear instrumentalization by some of the accusation of antisemitism in order to liquidate undesirables, to destroy their reputation,” Schäfer says. Only 1 left in stock - order soon. Wenn Schriftsteller ihren Freitod schreibend vorwegnehmen. A mighty helicopter appears over a clearing in the middle of the Black Forest. Sich der BDS-Bewegung anzuschließen, die Israel als Ganzes ablehnt und beispielsweise israelische Wissenschaftler und Künstler boykottiert, selbst wenn sie sich kritisch gegenüber der Besatzungspolitik Netanjahus äußerten, könne sie natürlich nicht, sagt Neiman. $3.84 shipping. Artists who have been accused of anti-Semitism include the London-based author Kamila Shamsie, who was stripped of the Nelly Sachs Prize by the city of Dortmund, and the rapper Tali Kweli, whose invitation to participate at the Open Source Festival in Düsseldorf was withdrawn. Susan Neiman im Gespräch mit Vladimir Balzer. She has written extensively on the juncture between Enlightenment moral philosophy, metaphysics, and politics, both for scholarly audiences and the general public. 8 Dec 2019 – Susan Neiman has written a remarkable book, Learning from Others: Race and the Problem of Evil (Farrar, Straus, and Giroux, 2019). Die Philosophin Susan Neiman, Direktorin am Einstein Forum in Potsdam, gehört zu den Unterzeichnern einer Petition der "Initiative GG 5.3 Weltoffenheit", die sich nach eigenen Angaben für die Wahrung der Meinungsfreiheit im Umgang mit der BDS-Bewegung ausspricht. Sie stehe aber als Jüdin und israelische Bürgerin selbstverständlich für das Existenzrecht des Staates Israel ein. 5 were here. (Deutschlandfunk Kultur, Wortwechsel, 11.12.2020), "Identitätspolitik stellt sich in ihrer Zuspitzung selbst ein Bein", "Es ist okay zu sagen: Ich kann nicht mehr", Lange Nacht über Lebensentwürfe ohne Kind, Philosophie der Pause - Nichtstun ist wie sterben üben (Gespräch), Linkenpolitiker Fabio de Masi - Identitätspolitik kann linker Politik schaden, Exit. Its sliding door is open. Mit Lucy Wilke suchen wir nach konkreten Handlungsansätzen.Mehr, Keine Drehs, kein Theater, kein Geld: Die Coronabeschränkungen treffen Freie im Theater besonders hart. Historiker Johannes Fried zum Christentum. On December 9, 30 leading German cultural institutions issued a statement opposing a resolution directed against the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement passed by the German parliament (Bundestag) a year and a half ago. To order a copy go to guardianbookshop.com or call … View the profiles of people named Susan Neiman. The backlash didn’t take long; it ranged from nuanced responses such as those of Eva Illouz, Susan Neiman, and Aleida Assmann to defensive statements that were deaf to problematic aspects of Mbembe’s texts and blind to his activities, which, while not part of BDS in the narrow sense, were certainly aimed in a similar direction. The Bundestag resolution demanded the withholding of any public spaces and financial support to organisations and individuals with any sort of connection to BDS, or who sympathise with its aims. In 2018, the director of the Jewish Museum in Berlin, Peter Schäfer, was forced to resign after holding a podium discussion with the Jewish philosopher and feminist Judith Butler and the anti-Zionist professor Micha Brumlik. There have been previous cases of attempts to suppress the BDS. Written by Susan Neiman. Die im Juni 2010 an der Uni Siegen aus der Liste L.S.D. ", Die BDS-Bewegung sei keine Organisation im herkömmlichen Sinn, sagt Neiman. She lives in Berlin and is the director of the Einstein Forum in Potsdam. More than 400 Jewish scholars, mainly from the United States, Israel and Germany, protested against Schäfer’s resignation, which came in the wake of huge political pressure from the Israeli embassy. She explained that she has taken German citizenship after Donald Trump was elected US president. Es ist schon erstaunlich, dass diese Initiative eine solche Debatte hervorgebracht hat. Brumlik criticized the accusations against Schäfer as a sign of the decline in left-liberal cultural circles, likening it to a new form of McCarthyism directed against all those “suspected of some sort of support for the BDS.”, The artistic director of the Berliner Festspiele, Thomas Oberender, who signed the declaration against the government’s BDS resolution, said in practice it led to “revoking invitations to artists and scholars who have worked in Germany for many years and whose work has never violated the values of our Basic Law.”, Hartmut Dorgerloh, the general director of the Humboldt Forum Foundation in Berlin, pointed to the growing influence of far-right radicalism in German public life and declared, “We are living at a time when rational behaviour is being disregarded at the highest political level. The German government and its anti-Semitism commissioner, Felix Klein, have sharply rejected the statement by cultural activists. As an example of the negative consequences of the Bundestag resolution, the declaration cites the case of the Cameroonian historian and political researcher Achille Mbembe. Susan Neiman was born on March 27, 1955, in Atlanta, Georgia, United States, in a Jewish family. Debatte über BDS-Bewegung - "Antizionisten interessieren sich nicht für Palästinenser"(Deutschlandfunk Kultur, Fazit, 19.12.2020), Pro-palästinensische BDS-Bewegung - Antisemitismus oder nur Kritik an Israels Regierung? The Israeli state has drafted an extensive blacklist of individuals who are denied entry to the country due to links to BDS. Mbembe is only one of many who have been accused and censored as a result of the Bundestag resolution. The German government repeated its mantra that the State of Israel’s right to exist was non-negotiable. Susan Neuman is an educator, researcher, and education policy-maker in early childhood and literacy development. Philosophy in Transit by Susan Neiman (2014-09-25) Jan 1, 1765. "Es gibt keinen Vorstand, es gibt keine Gremien. The work-weathered hands of Henry Brooks, a former slave … 13.12.2020 - 16:48 , Hanno Hauenstein Share. She has written extensively on the juncture between Enlightenment moral philosophy, metaphysics, and politics, both for scholarly audiences and the general public. The cultural initiative was supported by internationally renowned institutions such as the Berliner Festspiele, the Deutsches Theater Berlin and the Alliance of International Production Houses, academic institutions such as the Einstein Forum Potsdam, the Berlin College of Science, the Centre for Research on Anti-Semitism at the Technical University of Berlin, as well as state-related organisations such as the Goethe-Institute, the Federal Cultural Foundation, the Humboldt Forum Foundation and Berlin’s House of World Culture. Susan Neiman is an American moral philosopher, cultural commentator, and essayist. Israel boycott and BDS in Germany – a dispute – culture. Susan Neiman is an American writer and philosopher. Germany’s historical responsibility should “not lead to a blanket moral or political delegitimisation of other historical experiences of violence and oppression. Modelled on the movement against apartheid in South Africa, BDS calls for a boycott of Israel and demands, among other things, an end to the occupation of Arab lands, the demolition of the wall around the occupied territories, legal equality for Jews and Arabs and the right of return for Palestinian refugees, as agreed in UN Resolution 194. ", Deswegen gebe es auch Juden, die die BDS-Bewegung unterstützten, sagt Neiman. This meant, de facto, the suppression of any criticism of the foreign policy of the German government, which, despite occasional tactical differences, pursues its own imperialist goals in the Middle East in close cooperation with Israel—one of the most important markets for Germany’s arms industries. "Schön wäre es, wenn das möglich wäre. Aber ein Blick auf die Landkarte zeigt, dass die Siedlungspolitik von Netanjahus Regierung, die schon vorher angefangen hat, aber unter ihm verstärkt wurde, einen palästinensischen Staat unmöglich macht. A motion opposing this ban was initially rejected by Germany’s Administrative Court. Criticism of the Israeli government must be possible, she said: “According to the logic of the BDS resolution, neither Albert Einstein nor Hannah Arendt would be allowed to give a lecture in Germany because, although they supported the state of Israel, they were both very critical of the unjust treatment of the Palestinians.”. She currently lives in Berlin. The latter organisations fear that the suppression of all criticism of Israel will endanger their work in other countries, but the main driving force of the declaration is the concern that suppressing critical views plays into the hands of right-wing, authoritarian tendencies and stifles the freedom of culture. She was interested in Simone de Beauvoir's and Jean-Paul Sartre's books. “The common fight against anti-Semitism, racism, right-wing extremism and any form of violent religious fundamentalism is at the heart of our initiative,” the statement reads. In the UK, former Labour Party leader Jeremy Corbyn was suspended temporarily and tens of thousands of his supporters purged from the party on drummed-up charges of anti-Semitism. Neiman noted that Albert Einstein had called on Israel to protect the rights of Arabs and had called the Deir Yassin massacre “fascist”. Education Susan Neiman dropped out of high school at the age of fourteen to join the anti-Vietnam War movement. A spokesman for the Foreign Office said that its officials had ruled out any cooperation with the BDS movement before the resolution was passed and had refrained from supporting any means which could promote the BDS. When it came to the vote, the AfD faction abstained only because it had put forward its own, even harsher motion, calling for a ban on BDS. Das ist ein Grund, warum ich nicht dazu stehe.". The name refers to the clause dealing with the freedom of art and science enshrined in Article 5 (3) of Germany’s Basic Law. BDS-Resolution des Bundestages - Zensur von Wissenschaft und Kultur? Mbembe was invited to give the opening speech to this year’s Ruhrtriennale but was then confronted with a wave of accusations of anti-Semitism after he described the Israeli occupation of Palestine as a form of colonialism and compared it to the apartheid policy of South Africa. Statement by German cultural institutions on the parliamentary BDS resolution by the Bundestag As representatives of public cultural and research institutions in Germany, we share a mandate from the state to promote arts and culture, historical research and democratic education and to make these accessible to the general public. Im Mai 2019 folgte der Bundestag einem gemeinsamen Antrag von CDU/CSU, SPD, FDP und den Grünen und beschloss, der umstrittenen BDS-Bewegung (Boycott, Divestment and Sanction) Unterstützung und finanzielle Förderung zu entziehen. In Germany, the number of anti-Semitic crimes by far-right radicals increased sharply last year and more and more cases of anti-Semitism and pro-Nazi tendencies have been uncovered in the German police and the armed forces. Aber es gibt noch viel zu diskutieren und wir planen eine Reihe von Veranstaltungen, in denen wir hoffen, diese schwierige Diskussion in die Öffentlichkeit zu bringen und über die schwierige Lage in Nahost sprechen zu können.". 3.6 out of 5 stars 12. Sie sei überzeugt, "wer heute zu Israel stehen will, der muss die Politik Netanjahus kritisieren. The Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism is a tool to identify, confront and raise awareness about antisemitism as it manifests in countries around the world today. Beitrag hören Podcast abonnieren Susan Neiman is the author of Learning from the Germans. NEIMAN, Susan 1955-PERSONAL:Born March 27, 1955, in Atlanta, GA; children: Benjamin, Shirah, Leila. Anti-Semitism, i.e., the racial hatred of Jews, is an ideology associated with the extreme right. Domestically, it is aimed at criminalising those critical of the government and, in terms of foreign policy, justifying militarism and oppression in the Middle East and other parts of the world. Und deshalb war und bleibt die Initiative wichtig. The Bundestag resolution “Resolutely confronting the BDS movement—combating anti-Semitism” was put forward by the parliamentary groups of Germany’s governing grand coalition of the conservative Christian Democratic Union/Christian Social Union (CDU/CSU) and Social Democratic Party (SPD), together with the opposition parties Free Democratic Party and the Greens.